why i became catholic and not orthodox{ keyword }

We must read Sts Ambrose, Cyprian, and Augustine alongside not over or against the councils and the other fathers. It is also considered heresy by many Orthodox Christians as well but is now accepted by most Orthodox Christians. The Fathers of the Church do not contradict one another they all beheld the same uncreated light and testify truthfully concerning it within their specific historical contexts. Ever hear of Jamphedpur? The Orthodox Question: Why Catholic and Not Eastern Orthodox? Notice how none of the disparaging comments truly attempt to address your arguments and/or rational whether out of a respectable humility or a foul spirit of spite. Its either the Eastern orthodox or the Roman Catholicism. Christ bestow[ed] the favor of this title upon His disciple, so that HE TOO might be Peter [rock] (that is, the Rock of the Church in a vicarious sense). Many of the liturgical changes that were implemented after Vatican II, such as communion in the hand, extraordinary eucharistic ministers, the suppression of the minor orders, female altar servers, among many other things, are unacceptable to me and, in my opinion, need to be reversed. Seraphim Roses writing on this topic still stands https://youtu.be/ra17xm0yn3E Most of the people attacking it attempt to negate without actually engaging the arguments. If I ask any Orthodox- they say basically- move closer. Now some of the argument between Orthodoxy and Catholicism here gets into the weeds of exactly what kind of authority the Pope was supposed to have. He goes even further by claiming that the immaculate heart of Mary is actually the true teachings of the Orthodox Church but the Theotokos needed a way to communicate this to peasant children. 7. There is indeed disunity within the Orthodox Church, and the fact we are so disunited, yet we still exist, proves that the gates of hell havent prevailed over us despite the countless attempts of the devil to destroy us. the better; but I had never conceived of Catholicism as a sort of showy attribute or attraction to be tacked on to my own national body, but as the inmost soul of the true body, wherever it might be. A Catholic is free to agree or disagree with the council. p. 72), the coryphaeus of the apostolic choir; he is the first disciple of Christ and speaks always on behalf of all. . Could he not, then, strengthen the faith of the man to whom, acting on his own authority, he gave the kingdom, whom he called the rock, thereby declaring him to be the foundation of the Church [Matt. 8 Reasons Why I'm Catholic not Orthodox Required fields are marked *. This disunity is not just in communion. Privacy Policy. On Fatima: There is a movement among Eastern Catholics called the Zoghby Initiative, started by Melkite Catholic Archbishop Elias Zoghby. the Lord Jesus Christ, the incarnate Son of God Himself may be forgiven men, as it may be uttered in error or in ignorance and, subsequently may be covered by conversion and repentance (an example of such a converted and repentant blasphemer is the Apostle Paul. I discovered that the Catholic Church has stayed with the successor to the apostle Peter, which was one of the major deciding factors for me. The devil mixes truths with lies. Since the goodness which proceeds by generation from intellectual goodness as from a source is the Word, and since no intelligent person could conceive of a word without spirit, for this reason the Word, God from God, possesses also the Holy Spirit proceeding together with him from the Father. At Nicea a proposed law was to forbid all bishops, priests and deacons, who were married at the time of their ordination, to continue to live with their wives. Anyways, my commentary could go on and on but this was the point I wanted to make. I encourage you to do your own research. Welcome to Issuus blog: home to product news, tips, resources, interviews (and more) related to content marketing and publishing. In Orthodoxy, everyone is implicitly saying that everyone elses jurisdictions are illicit by placing overlapping bishops abroad. Fatima was true and Orthodoxy is true. However i also know that in holy statues blessed by priest also miracles happen likewise. Basil supports the idea that this victim-husband is not bound by the obligations of that continually existing bond until his first spouse dies. Thats why I have distanced myself from a lot of hardline Orthodox Christians like you because theres no charity or love in your words. In addition, Our Lady requested that Russia, the largest Orthodox country, be consecrated by the Pope, the head of the Catholic Church, to the immaculate heart (a Catholic devotion rejected by many Orthodox as heretical) so that it will be converted. A literal mention on the Arians shows why the Canons did accept their conversion without rebaptism, this time from Pope Saint Innocent I (+417 a.D.): As for the Arians and other similar plagues, the fact that we adopt their lay people, when they turn to the Lord, under the symbol of penitence and sanctification of the Holy Ghost, through the imposition of the hand does not indicate that their clergy ought to be adopted with the dignity of the priesthood or of any ministerial rank. St. Gregory says. You pontificate (pun intended) against Gideon as if you argue from fact, calling him poorly catechized and very confused. Catholic missionary work continued after the schism. You cant have piety without truth & orthodoxy. His own 1926 book The Catholic Church and Conversion (pdf copy here), especially about the 3 stages in "Chapter III : The Real Obstacles", quoted by Catholic apologist Dave Armstrong blog article Catholic Conversion: Classic Analyses (Chesterton, Belloc, Pelikan). This may sound very uninformed, but I am a former protestant so Im still trying to learn. Just enjoy Gods mercy and love in His Word and His Sacraments especially the Blessed Sacrament. Because to them, it was not either/or, but both/and! This is essentially a way to avoid the fact that these Orthodox sacramental rigorists would have to think that there are large numbers of lay people running around the Church thinking they are clergy. Yes, he wrote that quote, but what is it about? Infants do not go to confession. From the standpoint of critical scholarship it can no longer be disputed that Jesus words to Peter as reported in Matt 16:17-19 confer a special distinction on Peter as rock the foundation on which Christ promised to build his Church. And yet, the wife who commits adultery is not to be received by the husband ever again, in order to avoid the inevitable pollution of uniting with a harlot. Why I Did Not Become Roman Catholic - Orthodox-Reformed Bridge Here then the wife, if she leaves her husband and goes to another, is an adulteress. The Church never claims all her members will act impeccably at all times. Question: If the Orthodox faith is the only true faith, can Christians of other confessions be saved? Thats exactly why Pope John VIII and Pope Leo III explicitly condemned it and called it heresy; they must never have been real popes! https://t.co/OkS6TgPlIS?amp=1, https://t.co/TbE2reJtvT?amp=1, https://t.co/UGPq8uVOIO?amp=1, https://t.co/XK1DWZ1xLj?amp=1, https://t.co/zOP5C6ryUL?amp=1. If the West does not wish to be punished, it must repent, consecrating itself to the Mother of God, as Russia has done, and so return to the Orthodox Faith after its near-millennial apostasy to materialism. However, basically no one recognized the OCA and overlapping parishes remain. Is the Catholic Magesterium in favor of hard liquor prohibition? How could you forget some of our major missionaries like St. Innocent of Alaska, St. Cosmas of Aetolia, and St. John Maximovitch among many others? However, this introduces far more ecclesiological problems than it solves. Anyway, I digress. It is easy to accuse Gideon of being poorly catechized, but if you then start off with such uninformed argument, you undercut your own credibility. So in spite of the hideous manipulation and abuses of many Roman clergy down through the ages (that make Jacob and Rachels stunt to secure the birthright seem like innocent childs play), the official teaching of the Catholic Churches- Roman and Eastern- remains consistently faithful to that of Christ and His Apostles. So while not maybe infallible, they are still authoritative and must be believed and submitted to. As I write this article, the largest Orthodox Church, the Russian Church, and the most powerful one, the Constantinople, are not in communion with one another. A few people have asked me why I chose the Catholic Church over the Orthodox Church (or churches, since there are several autocephalous and autonomous Orthodox churches based on region such as Russia, Greece, Antioch, etc.). Moving onto theological objections, one of the most common Orthodox objections to the papacy is that the rock was Peters confession of faith, not Peter himself. Your email address will not be published. A new 2011 biography G.K. Chesteron: A Biography by "the world's authority on John Henry Newman" Dr. Ian Ker, especially Chapter 11 (America and Conversion) Section 6, covering the letters, events, and recollections in the months preceding the 30 July 1922 conversion and the immediate reactions afterwards. Say more by seamlessly including video within your publication. I had been told by my fellow Orthodox Christians that Fatima was at best a hoax and at worst demonic, so I decided to investigate Fatima for myself. Evangelism is DEAD in the Orthodox church. If anyone is unwilling or not ready to submit to the Church in all areas of life, they should stay awayuntil or unless they are ready to do so. Yet custom ordains that men who commitadulteryand are in fornication be retained by their wives. Many Orthodox are more moderate. And, as I mentioned in my main article Why did I become a Catholic? The Rosary begins with the sign of the cross and In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Reddit, Inc. 2023. the Bishop of the Church of Alexandria, St. Dionysios (248-264), wrote : Inasmuch as you have written thus, setting forth the pious legislation, which we continually read and now have in remembrancenamely that it shall suffice only to lay hands on those who shall have made profession in baptism, whether in pretense or in truth, of God Almighty and of Christ and of the Holy Spirit; but those over whom there has not been invoked the name either of Father or of Son or of the Holy Spirit, these we must baptize, but not rebaptism. The Churches do not act like one Church in missionary work. . The mind of the Church as to the necessity of observing the trinitarian formula in this sacrament has been clearly shown by her treatment of baptism conferred by heretics. Thats just with the filioque not to mention your arguments for the papacy as one other person has already pointed out. The other key part of this passage is verse 19, where Peter receives the keys. So I shifted the focus of my research to the Catholic Church. Best wishes! The Russian Orthodox ChurchsDepartment for External Church Relations, whose Chairman is Metropolitan Hilarion of Volokolamsk, himself directly appointed by Patriarch Kyrill of Moscow as Vicar to the Patriarch of Moscow and All Russia, came out with the following statements with respect to re-marriage, and youll see the reference to St. Once sin is not understood as an offence and giving reparation, but a hereditary corruption of our nature, these cacodoxies are ground to dust. (See the Letter of Clement to the Romans, the letter of Ignatius to the Romans, and Irenaeus Against Heresies 3.3.2). God bless you, brother. Regarding the liceity of its issue to the creed, this is really an issue of papal authority which I already addressed. Frankly Ive been very disappointed and discouraged with Orthodoxy. Question what was incorrect on what I said. Orthodox often appeal to this to prove that Rome is just power hungry. You are Peter (Petros), and on this rock (petra) I will build my church (ecclesia). These words are spoken in Aramaic, in which Cephas stands both for petros and petra.The confession of Peter, therefore, cannot be separated from Peter himself. Are the sacraments of the Greek Old Calendarists valid since ROCOR was in communion with them? Perhaps if I were living near one of those churches, I might have become an Orthodox Christian. In the final verses of Matthew, Jesus issues the Great Commission: And Jesus came and said to them, All authority in heaven and on earth has been given to me. They have a Saviour Who desires the salvation of every human being. JESUS IS THE HOLY SPIRIT, YOU NEVER REFER IT TO IT AS A GHOST. GOT IT ?? Seraphim Rose actually wrote a whole book defending St. Augustine called The Place of Blessed Augustine in the Orthodox Church. This could not be further from the truth. I read that as meaning places in India were there were not already Portuguese settlements (such as Goa.) Lastly, the Virgin Mary taught the children a new prayer to include in the Rosary, O my Jesus, forgive us our sins, save us from the fires of hell. Chesterton wrote a series of letters to Knox. The fact he even raised this question reveals his ignorance of psychology. But we obviously do hold that the Roman Catholics believe many wrong things about Christ, and we hold that the sacraments properly belong to the Church, and so do not exist in groups that have cut themselves off from the Church. Let us pray for each other! I will pray for you and I send you love in Christ our Lord. And the Council of Arles, in canon 8, is very clear as well: Concerning the Africans, because they follow their own peculiar law and rebaptize: It is determined that if someone come to the Church from heresy, let them ask him his Creed; and if they see that he has been baptized in the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, only is the hand to be imposed upon him, so that he may receive the Holy Spirit. 7. www.quora.com Obviously you arent orthodox. Why Don't Eastern Catholics Just Become Orthodox? IOW, if Orthodoxy has FAILED (and this is not really debatable) to make disciples of all nations (being largely confined to the boundaries of a few countries such as those named above), then doesnt this suggest that Orthodoxy is disqualified as the one true Church because it has NOT done what Jesus commanded the Church to do? The Jesuits in particular were seen as devious and dishonest for their views on equivocation. Toledo never proclaimed this cacodoxy. Sorry about that! By Athanasius Yoo, M.D., B.D. Aquinas starts the Summa Theologiae by discussing how we know things. This entire objection of the filioque originated because of Photius. To be Anglican is to be part of the catholic church. There is also a Catholic prophecy from Our Lady of La Salette Rome will loss the faith and become the seat of the Anti-Christ. Plus being PERSECUTED AND TORTURED BY OUR SO CALLED PERFECT CHRISTIAN CRUSADES WHO HAVE thrown US to the side like a minority !!! Congratulations on converting to modernist Catholicism.

192 Bloomfield Ave, Bloomfield, Nj, Davidson County Court Date Lookup, Santa Cruz Camping Beach, Simply Meg's Photos Greensboro Nc, Articles W